The Boxtrolls
(2014)
I’m not quite sure how The
Boxtrolls scored an Oscar nomination for Best Animated Feature. Perhaps it
was purely on the basis of the stop motion craftsmanship, rather than the film
as a whole? It’s good news for Laika, the studio behind it, which is three-for-three
in Academy Awards nods (or four-for-four, including their contract work on Corpse Bride), but in terms of
storytelling they’re suffering diminishing returns.
Perhaps this is explained by the quality of the source
material of their first feature, Coraline.
Certainly, it’s way out in front of both this and Paranorman. And Paranorman is
superior in turn to The Boxtrolls.
Based on Alan Snow’s 2006 novel Here Be
Monsters!, Graham Annable and Antony Stacchi’s movie (from a screenplay by
Travis Knight and David Ichioka) concerns the attempts to exterminate the
titular creatures from the town of Cheesebridge. Take a wild guess as to its
most prolific product; the fromage-based gags are actually one of the picture’s
better features.
Laika have been bigged up as a progressive studio, but their
commentary on prejudice and class boundaries here is as subtle as an Edam
brick. The trolls are made out to be child-eating monsters, pursued by pest
exterminator Archibald Snatcher (Ben Kingsley). Of course, nothing could be
further from the truth. Everyone judges by appearances, and beneath their
grotesque, grunting exteriors lurk hearts of gold. They raise a boy named Eggs
(Game of Thrones’ Isaac
Henpstead-Wright) as their own and, equipped with his very own troll box, he
believes himself to be one of their kind (somehow, Eggs also develops the
ability to speak human). The Boxtrolls are merely the lowest rung of the class ladder.
Their oppressor, Snatcher, longs to sit at high (cheese) table with the council
of White Hats who run Cheesebridge. He has been dangled the carrot of his very
own white hat if he rids the town of Boxtrolls.
On the council is Lord Portley-Rind (Jared Harris), a remote
and absent father whose stuck up daughter Winnie (Elle Fanning) becomes
entangled in the fates of Eggs and the Boxtrolls. This is fairly crude stuff,
perfectly admirable in terms of moral lessons, but too schematic to really have
a heart. Eggs isn’t just an orphan urchin, but the offspring of the town’s
greatest inventor, one of such estimable character that he made friends and
entertained the Boxtrolls while other shunned them. The picture is too nice to
really have any teeth beneath its surface level fascination with bodily
function jokes and utterly evil schemes; none of the trolls have been exterminated after all, and
Eggs’ dad is perfectly all right (well, as much as he can be voiced by Simon
Pegg).
While the stop motion animation is very good, there’s
something possible a bit too polished about it, as if the edges have been rubbed
off. It’s no wonder some have mistaken it for CGI (particularly when studios
have gone down the route of producing CGI animations in stop motion style).
There’s a grotesquery to the designs that, the Snatcher aside, comes across as
rather generic and lacking in flair. Added to this, the colour palate is
unremittingly dull and muddy, as if Laika are intent on sucking all vitality
from the screen.
If the technical side is accomplished, it’s rarely matched
by the onscreen antics, then. There’s one absolute standout, and that’s Ben
Kingsley’s villainous voice work as Snatcher. It’s one to cherish, up there
with his OTT characters in Sexy Beast
and Iron Man Three, and the animators
are clearly enthused by the opportunity to add body to the part. Snatcher is
visualised with more than a touch of Timothy Spall by way of Gerald Scarfe,
complete with an allergic reaction to cheese that causes him to hallucinate;
the latter owes a debt to Eddie Murphy’s rubbery transformations in Nutty Professor.
Kingsley relishes Snatcher’s malicious glee, and the
exaggeration of his character is the closest Boxtrolls comes to Roald Dahl-esque black comedy (with a bit of Monty Python’s Meaning of Life thrown in
for his explosive demise). The makers are careful even here, however, offering
Snatcher redemption (“They don’t make
you. You make you,” pleads Eggs/the Trubshaw Baby, addressing the illusory
nature of Snatcher’s sought-after acceptance by high society).
Kingsley also has the chance to double up, as Madame
Frou-Frou Snatcher’s anti-Boxtroll propaganda spouting alter ego. That Lord
Portley-Rind finds Frou-Frou alluring is typical of picture that only goes in
obvious directions, however (“Oh my God,
I regret so much” he comments on learning the truth). They’ve even cast
Nick Frost and Richard Ayoade as henchmen, whose initially clever dialogue (“You really think these Boxtrolls understand
the duality of good and evil?”) grows stale. Even the meta- discussion at
the end is a bit of a fizzle.
It isn’t unusual for the villains or supporting characters
in an animation to be the strongest part of the picture, but in The Boxtrolls the leads are particularly
weak. There isn’t much to them, aside from tapping into kids’ fascination with
vulgarity (wee jokes, bare bottoms, eating grubs, regurgitating food). I’m not
sure if the stiffy joke at the end was intentional (one of the now-naked trolls
holds out a remote control in a suggestive position), but it wouldn’t be a
surprise (there are gags about scratching one’s privates).
Stop motion animation can find wide audiences, as Aardman
has proved, if not nearly as wide as CGI, but Laika appears to be ploughing a
perversely narrow path of over-earnest moralising, unattractive design work and
charmless characterisation. If their storytelling were up to the standard of
their technique, they’d be bagging the Best Animated Picture Oscar every time.
