What’s Christmas but a time for finding yourself a year older and not a day richer? There’s nothing merry in that.
Scrooge
(1970)
(SPOILERS) The most charitable thing one can say about Scrooge the musical is that it was bound
to happen at some point. It isn’t even necessarily a bad idea. It could work. Indeed, it did work two decades later when the
Muppets tried it. Which rather highlights the big problem with this picture; it’s
no fun.
As taglines go, “What
the dickens have they done to Scrooge?” is laying yourself open for
invective, but the film was an easy sell to awards ceremonies, inclined as a
matter of course towards sumptuous musicals. It was nominated for a BAFTA,
gathered a handful of Golden Globes (I know, as meaningless as it gets, thus Albert
Finney took a Best Actor award) and four Oscar noms (tellingly, none were in
major categories). It’s always fun to disagree with Pauline Kael’s critiques,
but she had Scrooge thoroughly banged
to rights when she hauled it over the coals. She accused it of the crime of
playing it tediously safe; “If you make
it tastefully dull, you stand a very good chance of coming out with a picture
that will be acclaimed a screen classic”.
I’m not sure that has happened, but its perennial small
screen presence reserves it just that kind of festive status. The fact that IMDB
(a mystifying 7.5 average) seems to rate it, and that somehow – presumably
because the big-screen-musical-to-stage reversal is now so commonplace – it’s
oft revived for touring (Anthony Newley and Tommy Steele both took the title
role), shouldn’t blur its limited appeal. “Will
children enjoy it? I doubt whether they will, much” Kael answered her own
question. Scrooge is the sort of
Christmas movie no one sits down to watch with their undivided. They have it on
in the background, so it assumes the status of slightly less static festive decor.
Only slightly, though.
Albert Finney had done relatively little cinema following
his (rightly) acclaimed international breakout in Tom Jones, and he initially turned the Ebenezer role down (others
offered the part included Richard Harris and Rex Harrison, both of whom would
have been much better suited). As with Murder
on the Orient Express, but much less fun – Finney doesn’t quite go ham-side
up, but rather, as Kael commented “plays
it glumly and realistically, a terrible mistake” – this finds the actor donning
layers of makeup to accomplish an “astonishing” physical transformation. A
young 33-year-old becomes an old man! But Finney’s choices weren’t in the aid
of dramatic or mesmerising results, as per Brando’s Vito Corleone a couple of
years later. Instead, they smacked of classic theatrical vanity, literally
disguising oneself with one’s art; his performance suggests Alfred Steptoe
sucking a lemon while encountering the first stages of a stroke. Even Bill
Oddie did a more convincing old man – old Bill – in The Goodies episode The End.
And he wasn’t trying.
The less-than-compelling casting extends to his strangely
under-amped support. Alec Guinness (who really
didn’t enjoy the experience, understandably, as the flying harness gave him a
double hernia) is okay, but that’s about the worst thing you can say about one
of his performances. Kenneth More barely registers as the Ghost of Christmas
Present, but his fake beard partly makes up for it. Nephew Fred is chipper, but
that’s about it (Michael Medwin, 13 years older than Finney and in desperate
need of rejuvenating cream to convince as a passably flourishing younger man).
Only David Collings manages to breathe life into the material, making a fine,
moving fist of Bob Cratchit. But it isn’t enough. As for when Tiny Tim starts
singing… Gawd help us, every one.
Scrooge is
possessed of that unerring competence Hollywood could still apply to the
musical at that time, even though they were entering a terminal decline,
rubbing the wrong way against the new generation of wunderkinds and evolving
tastes. As such, alarm bells should triggered at Fox when they secured the
services of Leslie Bricusse to pen the screenplay and lyrics – Kael again, on
the writer: “the name of a form of
instantly disposable music; your mind flushes it away while you’re hearing it”
– ouch, but true) – since he’d written Fox’s last song and dance bomb, Dr Doolittle (later, much later, he’d
pen Michael Winner masterpiece Bullseye!)
Ronald Neame directs as statically and uninterestedly as only
a certain strain of transatlantically-inclined British directors of the time
were capable, rarely showing even a glimmer of style but somehow continually
getting re-employed (Michael Anderson was another). He’d go on to make The Poseidon Adventure and Meteor, before it dawned on studios that
giving him lots of cash might not yield the most compelling results (to be
fair, The Poseidon Adventure made a
lot of money, and as ‘70s disaster movies go, it’s one of the least offensive).
When Ebenezer descends into hell, you aren’t struck by the dreadful, oppressive
atmosphere so much as the polystyrene rocks.
Later, for a wrap up, Scrooge even dons a Santa outfit
(slightly anachronistic for a story set in 1860, but then it’s only a musical,
right). It shouldn’t need saying, but if you’re angling for a great Scrooge, where there’s palpable uplift
when Ebenezer turns over that new leaf, look no further than Alistair Sim’s
performance in the 1951 film. You’ll be as merry as a schoolboy. As giddy as a
drunken man. And the dancing will actually raise a smile.
Agree? Disagree? Mildly or vehemently? Let me know in the comments below.
Comments
Post a Comment